How to Insure a Damaged Building and/or a Building with Claims.

• 

• 

• 

• 

Is My Building Uninsurable??

It can be a frustrating experience to hear that your building is “uninsurable”. Oftentimes when a building has some unrepaired damage, a history of claims, or some other problem, many insurance professionals will simply shrug and say, “Sorry your building is probably uninsurable”. If you ever hear this, it usually means that that insurance professional actually doesn’t know how insure such a building. No building is uninsurable.

There are thousands of insurance companies in the US. For every possible type of property, there is an insurance company (or several) that specialize in insuring it. It is crucial to work with a knowledgeable broker who not only knows which carriers will insure damaged buildings, but also which coverage need to be added to the policy to fully protect you, the owner. This article will dive into how to properly insure a damaged building and/or a building with claims.

Insuring a Damaged Building

When a fire burns a portion of a home, or a burst pipe floods a couple floors of an apartment building, a common insurance scenario plays out. The owner files a claim with his/her insurance company, and that carrier pays the claim to cover the repairs. But then, upon renewal, the carrier cancels the policy and tells the owner to find insurance elsewhere. This can happen even while the building is still being repaired, or even before repairs have begun. The previous carrier may still be paying to repair the property, but meanwhile the building owner needs to seek new insurance for the now damaged property, in order to cover the property going forward.

Why does this happen? Insurance companies exist to make a profit, and when there is a claim they lose money. Insurance companies do not want to insure unprofitable clients. This is the basic rule that governs what an insurance company is willing to insure.

Simply put, when your insurance company starts losing money, your insurance coverage is in danger. It could be cancelled or non-renewed anytime at their request with only 30 days notice. This not only means that you need to shop for insurance again – it means that insurance has become much harder to find, because your building is damaged, and your claims history follows you.

Damaged buildings need insurance during the repair process. Vandalism, water damage, and fire damage are all real concerns while a building is being repaired. There are also other risks to consider when contractors and construction people are coming in and out of your building every day during the repair. Due to the increased risks of insuring a damaged building or a building under construction, many standard “admitted carriers” will likely decline to quote.

However there is a whole galaxy of options outside of the admitted market. These carriers specialize in insuring buildings that, for one reason or another, have been rejected (or priced out) of the admitted market. This includes damaged buildings, buildings with a history of claims, buildings under construction, and other unique situations.

Not every insurance professional knows how to access this portion of the insurance market. In fact, many insurance pros ONLY know how to shop the admitted market (or only have access to one single carrier); when those limited options offer only declines, that insurance pro waves the white flag. This can lead a building owner to (incorrectly) believe that their property needs to remain uninsured for the unforeseeable future.

Here at Mighty Oak, we know how to deal with these situations properly. We have relationships across the admitted AND the non-admitted markets , so we are able to provide quotes to any property owner who needs insurance, even those with damaged buildings.

We also have the experience to know which coverage must be added to a damaged building’s insurance policy in order to fully protect the owner. For example, a policy for a building under construction should probably include a coverage such as Builder’s Risk , while a policy for a vacant building needs to have the Vacant Property Exclusion removed prior to putting the policy in force. These (and other details) are what we look for when we help an owner of a damaged building acquire insurance.

Insuring a Building with Claims

What if your building isn’t damaged at all, but instead just has a long history of claims?

Earlier this year a homeowner contacted us with a predicament: her homeowner’s insurance had been cancelled after she filed one too many claims. Her house was in pristine condition, worth more than $2 million, yet it seemed like nobody could get her a homeowner’s insurance quote. Her claims history had made her “uninsurable” (or at least that’s what she feared).

For over ten years she had been with a standard carrier, just like all her neighbors. But one day a storm damaged her windows and caused a leak, so she filed a claim. The insurance company paid for the repairs. Soon after that, a tree fell on her fence – which meant another claim and another pay-out by the carrier. Finally a couple months after that, the neighbor’s landscape contractor backed over their lawn irrigation equipment and broke the sprinkler system. This claim cost the carrier another $5,000. Their insurance company canceled her policy about a month later, and their agent had no options to replace it. 

When she visited another broker, he checked with all the standard, admitted carriers, and received nothing but declines. Why? Because with every carrier he checked, he was required to explain her claims history. When these carriers heard about the claims, they refused to take on the risk.

None of these these claims were catastrophic, and none were wildly expensive. All were reasonable claims that any insurance company should expect to pay for. Yet just the fact that there were three claims in one year was enough for the client to be shut out of the standard market, even though her house was in excellent condition. When her broker received nothing but declines, he told her she may be uninsurable.

Of course, he was wrong; she was very much insurable. When she was referred to us by a friend, we performed a diligent search of carriers that are willing to take on clients with a history of claims. We found her some quotes that fully insured her property, and she is now insured once more.

Our brokerage specializes in helping owners of “distressed” properties, whether that means buildings under construction, damaged building, or buildings with a history of claims. We can even find insurance for buildings where damage has yet to be repaired. There is a carrier for every situation; no client is uninsurable. We will put our deep knowledge of the insurance market to work for any client that needs insurance, especially those who have been turned away by other brokers.